Hi Everybody!

I really don't understand the reason for this thread but have read the original post and Erich's well-written response.

I've only been here since last July when I stepped-in to handle the Trading Room and have never heard Erich mention Tom Loge. As far as I know, he hasn't had any part of Traders Helping Traders since I've been here. And Erich has never called daytrades in our Trading Room. I know, I've been there every day it's been open.

As I read it, Dan (the original Poster) wants Erich to produce statements from several years ago to prove certain trades were or were not taken? Why would this be raised now?

I get to see Erich's nightly trade calls and he does very well. However, they're only seen by subscribers so Dan likely hasn't been aware of the magnificent trades Erich has nailed since just last Summer (when I started getting them). Does he lose on occasion? Yes . . . and so do I when daytrading. But I've never seen Erich "shuck and jive" or otherwise avoid a losing recommendation. Erich is as honest as anyone I've ever known.

Now if there is something specific Dan wants me to investigate, all he has to do is send me an e-mail. I make no secret of how to contact me, but it's: THTTradingRoom@gmail.com

I think Erich was 100% right. Life is tough. Trading is tough. If someone is bitter (as Dan called himself), maybe that's a hurdle he needs to overcome before he can become profitable. Rather than stir-up something, why not sit-in with me and try daytrading? Living in the past doesn't really help anyone. OK?

I just wanted to add my 2-cents.

Best Regards,
Chartsky